From The Face to Arena: The Evolution of 1980s Masculinity


From The Face to Arena: The Evolution of 1980s Masculinity
When Nick Logan launched Arena in the autumn of 1986, he completed an unprecedented hat-trick in modern British magazine publishing. Having previously revamped the New Musical Express(NME) in the early 1970s, established Smash Hits for EMAP in 1978, and created the independent style bible The Face in 1980, Logan's launch of Arena marked the formal birth of the modern men's lifestyle magazine in Britain. While The Face had pioneered a post-modern visual language that merged music, street fashion, and subcultural politics for a mixed-gender audience, Arena narrowed its focus toward an affluent, metropolitan male readership. In doing so, Arenatransformed male consumerism from a subcultural visual experiment into a polished, high-end lifestyle project, fundamentally reshaping how masculine identity was represented, commercialised, and consumed.
1. Nick Logan's Publishing Hat-Trick: From Pop Gloss to Men's Lifestyle
The evolution of British magazine culture between 1978 and 1986 was largely driven by a single editorial lineage originating with Nick Logan. After stepping down as editor of the NME in 1978 to escape corporate committee publishing, Logan created Smash Hits, using high-gloss A4 paper and vivid color photography to celebrate the surface visual culture of popular music. Two years later, operating independently under his Wagadon imprint, Logan launched The Face in May 1980. Put together initially in the very same Carnaby Street office as Smash Hits with the assistance of art director Steve Bush, The Faceexpanded the visual grammar of Smash Hits into a broader, more cerebral examination of contemporary culture.
Although The Face was originally conceived as a general-interest title covering music, film, and fashion, its readership was divided equally between men and women. By 1986, recognizing an emerging shift in retail culture and advertising budgets, Logan identified a clear gap in the publishing market for a dedicated men's magazine that avoided the sleaze of top-shelf publications. Arena was launched to fill this void, establishing a template that proved men would purchase high-production lifestyle titles centered on fashion, grooming, culture, and design.
Publication | Launch Year | Target Audience | Editorial & Aesthetic Focus | Demographic Model |
Smash Hits | 1978 | Provincial youth & pop fans | Pop lyrics, 7-inch singles, color pin-ups, carnivalesque tone | Teen / Youth mainstream |
The Face | 1980 | Metropolitan style cognoscenti | Avant-garde typography, subcultural fashion, pop process | 50/50 Gender split |
Arena | 1986 | Affluent metropolitan men | High-end fashion, luxury goods, architectural design, culture | Dedicated male readership |
2. The Face and the Subcultural 'New Man': Style, Androgyny, and the Pop Process
To understand the visual language of Arena, one must first examine how The Face constructed the figure of the "New Man" during the early 1980s. As media theorist Sean Nixon observes in Hard Looks: Masculinity, Spectatorship and Contemporary Consumption, The Facepositioned popular music within what he terms the wider "pop process." Music was no longer evaluated solely as an isolated acoustic recording; instead, it was understood as an intricate web of dress codes, record sleeve design, star glamour, video aesthetics, and club culture.
Under the visual direction of Neville Brody, The Face challenged conventional representations of masculinity. Influenced by the New Romantic movement, 2-Tone ska sartorial coding, and post-punk imagery, the magazine frequently featured male subjects whose presentation disrupted normative heterosexual codes:
Androgyny and Ambiguity: Cover portraits of stars like David Bowie, Bryan Ferry, Boy George, and Adam Ant celebrated camp, dandyism, and visual artifice, presenting masculinity as a fluid, theatrical costume rather than an immutable biological essence.
Subcultural Elite Address: Unlike broadsheet music papers that addressed readers as aspiring musicians or political activists, The Face addressed its audience as active participants in an urban subcultural scene—clubbers, art students, and media workers who expressed identity through meticulous acts of stylistic consumption.
The Post-Modern Surface: As cultural theorist Dick Hebdige highlighted in his essay The Bottom Line on Planet One, The Faceprioritised visual imagery over traditional text, allowing the line between editorial photo-spreads and commercial fashion advertising to become purposefully porous.
3. The Birth of Arena (1986): Refining Style into Metropolitan Luxury
While The Face drew its energy from the subversive margins of street culture and night-club aesthetics, Arena represented a move toward spatial order, luxury, and professional restraint. Launched in the autumn of 1986 under Logan's Wagadon banner, Arena adapted the visual techniques pioneered by The Face for an older, wealthier, and more conventional male demographic.
As former Smash Hits editor Ian Cranna noted, The Face had become increasingly esoteric and high-fashion by the mid-1980s. Arenacounterpointed this hyper-stylised approach by offering a cleaner, more accessible presentation of male lifestyle. The magazine combined long-form journalism, architectural reviews, high-end menswear, and cultural profiles, creating a sophisticated environment for luxury brand advertising.
Whereas The Face reflected a 1980s counter-cultural impulse rooted in art school experimentation, Arena chimed with the rise of the city professional and the expansion of high-street retail culture. It replaced subcultural defiance with an understated, elegant code of consumer sophistication—the man who shopped for tailoring, premium toiletries, and designer goods without compromising his cultural credibility.
4. Theorising Consumer Masculinity: Frank Mort, Sean Nixon, and the Commodity Self
The emergence of The Face and Arena provided academic researchers with a rich case study for understanding how gender identity intersects with commercial culture. In Cultures of Consumption, historian Frank Mort argues that the 1980s witnessed a fundamental realignment in the commercial management of demand, wherein young men were targeted as explicit consumers of fashion, grooming, and personal identity for the first time in post-war Britain.
Sociologists Frank Mort and Sean Nixon identified several key factors that underpinned this transformation:
The Spatial Redefinition of Retail: The mid-1980s saw a total redesign of high-street retail spaces—typified by stores like Next, Burton, and designer boutiques—which encouraged men to view shopping as an active leisure pursuit rather than an embarrassing necessity.
The Visual Co-Option of Male Subjectivity: Magazines like Arena constructed a new "gaze" for male readers. Rather than positioning men strictly as active spectators of women, these titles trained men to look at other men—and themselves—as visual objects of style, grooming, and physical presentation.
The Expansion of Advertising Categories: As advertising executive Tony Quinn noted, economic prosperity in the mid-1980s created an affluent group of single men with disposable income. Arena provided a legitimate, prestige environment for advertisers selling premium cologne, suits, watches, and consumer electronics to reach this lucrative market.
5. Visual Contrasts: The Avant-Garde Surface of The Face vs. Arena's Architectural Restraint
The contrast between The Face and Arena is most visible in their respective layout structures and art direction. The Face, under Neville Brody, relied on radical typographical iconography, custom typefaces, displaced drop caps, and asymmetrical page grids that challenged basic legibility. It treated the printed page as a canvas for visual friction.
In contrast, Arena adopted a more architectural, grid-aligned, and spacious design philosophy. The layout favoured generous white space, classic typography, crisp black-and-white portraiture, and structured grid columns.
THE FACE (1980–1986) ARENA (1986 Onward)
├── Subcultural / Avant-Garde ├── Metropolitan / High-End Luxury
├── Radical Brody Typography ├── Clean Grid & Classic Serif Types
├── Porous Copy/Ad Boundaries ├── Clear Editorial vs Advertising Split
└── Mixed Gender (50/50 Split) └── Dedicated Male Lifestyle Focus
This structural shift reflected a broader cultural movement in the late 1980s from post-punk subcultural resistance to mature, professional consumer identity. While The Face presented style as a form of ideological provocation, Arena presented style as a refined signifier of personal success, taste, and cultural discrimination.
6. The Legacy of 1980s Men's Style Titles: Bridging Style Culture to the 1990s Magazine Boom
The publishing framework established by Nick Logan through The Face and Arena laid the structural foundation for the UK magazine boom of the 1990s. Prior to Arena, publishing executives widely believed that general-interest men's magazines were commercially unviable in Britain. Arena's success proved that men would buy monthly lifestyle publications, directly paving the way for British editions of GQ (1988) and Esquire (1991).
However, as the 1990s unfolded, the sophisticated, art-school-educated tone of The Face and Arena was eventually eclipsed by the populist "lad magazine" phenomenon led by Loaded (1994) and FHM. Where Arena had addressed its reader as a cultured, style-conscious urbanite, 1990s lad mags reacted against 1980s "New Man" earnestness by celebrating a unreconstructed culture of drinking, football, and humour.
Despite this shift, the historical importance of The Face and Arenaremains indisputable. By dismantling the rigid separation between serious culture and commercial market forces, Nick Logan's titles proved that male identity, visual design, and consumer culture were inextricably linked, establishing a legacy that continues to define modern lifestyle journalism today.
Hill, S.A. (2009), Reconfiguring Authenticity in the Music Press 1978 to 1988 . PhD thesis. University of Southampton: Southampton.









Comments