"Like Punk Never Happened": Smash Hits and the Technicolor Rise of New Pop


Hill, S.(2010), ‘Smash Hits: Lost in the Seventies’, British Society and Culture in 1970s Britain, Newcastle-upon-Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Publishing
The late 1970s and early 1980s represent one of the most drastic paradigm shifts in the history of British music journalism and popular culture. In his landmark 1985 study Like Punk Never Happened: Culture Club and the New Pop, cultural critic Dave Rimmer posited a cyclical theory of popular music: every five years, established paradigms break down, giving rise to an entirely new aesthetic order. Just as punk rock had shattered the superannuated progressive rock mythologies of the mid-1970s, the emergence of "New Pop" in the wake of punk’s exhaustion swept away dour ideological posturing in favor of Technicolor visual spectacle, uninhibited pop hedonism, and an unashamed celebration of commercial artifice.
For decades, dominant rock historiography treated the interregnum between punk’s 1977 peak (Never Mind the Bollocks) and grunge’s 1991 explosion (Nevermind) as a cultural void—a period when, as Simon Reynolds notes, critical narratives implied that "nothing of real consequence happened." This erasure was fueled in part by an elitist disdain for New Pop’s perceived alignment with Thatcherite consumerism. As commentator Vince Egan observed, during the turn of the decade, dour, rain-sodden Marxist obscurantism gave way to hedonistic, fluorescent pop spectacle; wilful underground insularity yielded to mass-market brilliance.
Far from being an insipid commercial retreat, however, this transition marked a profound cultural revolution. At the very center of this revolution stood a single publication: Smash Hits. Launched by publisher EMAP in October 1978 under the visionary direction of former NME editor Nick Logan, Smash Hits fundamentally transformed how music was written about, visualized, and consumed, reacquainting British pop with what musicologist Simon Frith terms its essential "televisual aesthetic."
1. The Material Revolution: A4 Gloss, Technicolor, and the Rejection of Inky Broadsheets
To understand the impact of Smash Hits, one must first consider the physical landscape of the British music press in the late 1970s. For decades, music journalism was dominated by the traditional "inkies"—weekly newsprint broadsheets like the New Musical Express (NME), Melody Maker, and Sounds. These publications were smudgy, broadsheet-format weeklies printed on low-grade newsprint that literally left black ink on the reader’s fingers. Visually and ideologically, they were rooted in a 1960s rockist tradition that privileged austere text over image, investigative earnestness over visual flair, and underground "street credibility" over commercial pop success.
When Nick Logan launched Smash Hits in 1978—initially edited alongside Ian Cranna until 1981—he instituted a radical material departure:
Format and Paper Quality: Published in a sleek, glossy A4 format on high-grade paper, Smash Hits replaced smudgy newsprint with pin-sharp clarity and vibrant, full-color printing.
Visual Palette and Layout: Drawing inspiration from the luscious color photography of French titles like Paris Match and the vibrant graphic language of Pop Art and punk, Smash Hitsdeployed garish pinks, bright yellows, and dynamic cut-out layouts.
Interactive Artifacts: The magazine incorporated pull-out bedroom wall posters, collectible stickers, and full, verified song lyrics—treating pop culture items as cherished physical artifacts of daily adolescent life.
This material transformation was not merely decorative; it was an ideological necessity. As Mark Ellen, who later edited the magazine, famously remarked, the emerging stars of New Pop—acts like Duran Duran, Culture Club, Spandau Ballet, Wham!, Blondie, and Adam and the Ants—simply "did not work on horrible old inky smudgie broadsheet paper." Their visual identities, defined by ostentatious tailoring, makeup, hair gel, and cinematic music video aesthetics, required the pin-sharp clarity of high-gloss color printing. By rejecting the smudgy broadsheet format, Smash Hits declared that visual style was not a superficial distraction from musical substance, but an integral component of the pop text itself.
2. From New Journalism to Monoglottic Brilliance: Dismantling Rockist Hierarchy
Beyond its visual aesthetics, Smash Hits executed a decisive revolution in journalistic style. Throughout the 1970s, titles like the NME had been defined by what media theorist Eamonn Forde terms "polyglottism"—a style characterized by the "journalist-as-star." Writers like Tony Parsons, Julie Burchill, and Danny Baker adapted the New Journalism techniques pioneered in North America by Tom Wolfe and Hunter S. Thompson, crafting lengthy, self-absorbed, and highly polemical essays that frequently used recording artists as mere props for the writer's political or philosophical musings.
Smash Hits dismantled this self-important, rockist hierarchy by introducing an accessible, highly disciplined, and "monoglottic" editorial voice. Under the guidance of Nick Logan, Dave Hepworth (who edited the title from 1981 to 1983), and assistant editor Neil Tennant (who would later apply this exact pop reflexivity as frontman of Pet Shop Boys), the magazine replaced rambling critical grandstanding with concise, witty, and intellectually demanding prose.
Journalistic Dimension | Traditional 1970s Inkies (NME, Melody Maker) | The Smash HitsAesthetic (1978–1985) |
Physical Medium | Smudgy newsprint broadsheet; monochrome ink | Glossy A4 magazine; pin-sharp Technicolor printing |
Editorial Stance | Serious, polemical, rockist; suspicious of commercial sales | Irreverent, playful, reflexive; celebrating pop product |
Writer Persona | "Journalist-as-star"; New Journalism prose | Disciplined, witty, shared communal lexicon |
Target Audience | Elitist rock connoisseurs and underground purists | Broad mainstream pop consumers and youth culture |
Aesthetic Priority | Organic musical "authenticity" and singer-songwriter authorship | Visual spectacle, studio craft, and televisual artifice |
Rather than talking down to its adolescent audience, Smash Hitsconstructed a sophisticated, shared vocabulary. Editors and writers intentionally subverted traditional rock pomposity through affectionate satire, absurd nicknames, and a celebrated devotion to trivia. As Dave Hepworth famously declared, the magazine consciously planned to "reverse the tide of music coverage entirely in the direction of trivia," asserting that the specific color of a pop star's socks or their favorite TV show was far more illuminating than their thoughts on geopolitics.
By employing sophisticated literary devices—assonance, alliteration, outmoded Received Pronunciation phrasing used with dry comedic effect, and affectionate irony—Smash Hits invited its readers into an exclusive, highly literate club. It assumed high levels of cultural capital, demanding that readers decode subtle comedic cues while simultaneously validating their passion for chart-topping singles.
3. The Disco Sensibility and Pop Product: Celebrating Artifice over Authenticity
At the core of traditional rock ideology—what scholar Keir Keightley categorizes under "romantic" and "modernist" modes of musical legitimacy—was a deep-seated hostility toward commodified pop music. Since the late 1960s, rock criticism had relied on a Baudrillardian "deterrence machine," attempting to separate "authentic," self-authored rock music from "manufactured," commercial pop product.
Smash Hits completely shattered this artificial dichotomy by embracing what can be termed a "disco sensibility." As Dave Hepworth noted, while punk had maintained an over-inflated sense of its own historical importance, the true commercial and stylistic phenomenon of the late 1970s was disco. Disco challenged conventional rock authenticity by celebrating studio construction, producer authorship, dancefloor utility, and unapologetic consumer pleasure.
While Smash Hits was not exclusively a disco magazine, it operated with a disco philosophy:
Genre Parity: It established a completely level playing field where electronic synth-pop, post-punk, ska, reggae, disco, and heavy metal received equal critical dignity. A feature on Bob Marley or The Clash appeared alongside profiles of Donna Summer, Blondie, Madness, or The Police.
Acceptance of Pop Artifice: As Dave Rimmer pointed out, New Pop made no apologies for embracing the star system, conflating art, business, and entertainment without a trace of rockist guilt. Smash Hits treated a perfectly engineered three-minute 7-inch single as a triumph of modern cultural design.
Rejection of the "Authentic" Fallacy: The magazine recognized that all popular music—whether a raw punk single or a polished synth-pop anthem—is an artificially constructed studio product. By celebrating surface culture and visual flair, it exposed the fiction of rock's claims to unmediated "realness."
This philosophy was perfectly tuned to the UK music market of 1979–1980, which saw unprecedented commercial vitality, culminating in a record 86 million 7-inch single sales in 1979 alone. In an era when European disco beats collided with post-punk experimentation and Caribbean reggae rhythms, Smash Hitscaptured a mainstream pop scene that was gloriously diverse, innovative, and visually vibrant.
4. The Televisual Aesthetic and the Gateway to 1980s Lifestyle Publishing
Ultimately, the historical legacy of Smash Hits extends far beyond its immediate circulation triumphs. By foregrounding visual style, the magazine reacquainted British popular culture with what Simon Frith defines as pop's "televisual aesthetic." Frith argues that from the 1950s onward, popular music was constructed primarily in the recording studio and experienced visually through television (from Top of the Pops and American Bandstand to music video promos). Smash Hits understood that in a post-punk world, the way an artist looked on a television screen or in a promotional film was intrinsically linked to how their music was interpreted.
When MTV launched in North America in August 1981, it was the visually hyper-aware British acts celebrated by Smash Hits—Duran Duran, Culture Club, Eurythmics, Wham!, and Tears for Fears—that dominated the channel's 24-hour broadcast rotation. This "Second British Invasion" of the US charts was directly fueled by the televisual literacy that Smash Hits had cultivated in the UK music industry since 1978.
Furthermore, Smash Hits served as the crucial incubator for modern consumer lifestyle publishing. After establishing the magazine's blueprint at EMAP, Nick Logan departed in 1980 to launch The Face using his own capital. The Face took the visual polish and pop-process awareness pioneered at Smash Hits and applied it to an elite metropolitan style landscape. Later, in 1986, former Smash Hits editors Dave Hepworth and Mark Ellen launched Q magazine, adapting the accessible, highly structured consumer-guide review format for an older demographic of compact disc buyers.
By bridging the gap between punk's disruptive energy and the glossy video-pop era of the 1980s, Smash Hits proved that pop music did not need to pretend to be high art or political manifesto to be culturally profound. Through its Technicolor pages, witty prose, and unapologetic love for the three-minute single, Smash Hitscelebrated pop artifice as a vital, serious, and endlessly joyful art form—proving once and for all that pop culture was at its best when it acted like punk never happened.






Comments