Neil Tennant, Smash Hits and the Changing Language of Pop


Neil Tennant, Smash Hits and the Changing Language of Pop
When Neil Tennant resigned from his post as assistant editor of Smash Hits in 1985 to pursue a full-time career with Pet Shop Boys, he was not merely transitioning from music journalism to pop stardom. He was carrying an entire linguistic philosophy with him. Between 1982 and 1985, working out of EMAP’s cramped Carnaby Street office alongside Mark Ellen and Dave Hepworth, Tennant helped craft one of the most distinctive house styles in the history of British publishing.
Where the 1970s "inkies"—such as the New Musical Express, Melody Maker, and Sounds—approached popular music with solemn, politically charged prose derived from American New Journalism, Smash Hits invented a radically new register. It replaced heavy-handed rockist polemics with an erudite, chortlesome, and intensely self-reflexive pop vocabulary. In doing so, Tennant and his colleagues did not dumb down pop journalism; instead, they deconstructed the pomposity of rock culture while celebrating pop artifice with sharp intellectual wit.
The Newsroom Pioneer: Neil Tennant at Carnaby Street
Before "West End Girls" topped the UK and US charts in 1985, Neil Tennant spent three pivotal years as a core editorial architect of Smash Hits. Joining the fortnightly pop glossy during its imperial growth phase under EMAP, Tennant brought a uniquely sophisticated sensibility to the newsdesk. Having studied history at North London Polytechnic and worked as a commissioning editor for Marvel Comics, he possessed both a scholar's precision and a comic-book editor's eye for character and narrative exaggeration.
As former editor Mark Ellen later recalled, the editorial team behind Smash Hits comprised university-educated intellectuals who deliberately rejected the self-important posturing of traditional music critics. Rather than treating pop stars as untouchable icons or political tribunes, Tennant, Ellen, and Hepworth created an intimate, shared universe between the magazine and its adolescent readership. Tennant’s background at Marvel was particularly influential: he treated the pop chart as a colorful pantheon of recurring characters, transforming real-world musicians into vivid, larger-than-life figures while maintaining an affectionate, chortlesome tone.
From Polytechnic Pomp to Pop Fantasy: Deconstructing the Inkies
In his landmark study of music journalism, media theorist Eamonn Forde characterizes the transformation instituted by Smash Hits as a shift from "polyglottic" broadsheet journalism to a unified, "monoglottic" brand voice. Throughout the 1970s, titles like the NME relied on a competitive clash of individual personality writers—such as Nick Kent, Charles Shaar Murray, Julie Burchill, and Tony Parsons—who positioned themselves as central participants in the drama of rock authenticity.
Smash Hits discarded what Mark Ellen famously described as the "tedious and rather turgid polytechnic reasoning" of the broadsheet inkies. Instead of subjecting every seven-inch single to tortured socio-political interrogation, Smash Hits constructed what Forde terms an "incredible, fantasy parallel universe."
Publishing Dimension | 1970s Broadsheet Inkies (NME, Melody Maker) | 1980s Pop Glossies (Smash Hits) |
Editorial Architecture | Fragmented polyglottism (competing critic-stars) | Unified monoglottic house style |
Critical Lens | Anti-commercial rockism & social realism | Post-modern pop artifice & visual gloss |
Subject Construction | Tortured rock genius / political martyr | "Cartoon-like creature" / telegenic pop star |
Reader Address | Over-elaborate insider posture | Inclusive, curious, highly literate community |
This parallel universe operated on the assumption that pop music was inherently fun, fleeting, and visually magnificent. Pop stars were approached as "cartoon-like creatures," their personal quirks and stylistic choices amplified to the point of hyperbole. Yet, as Dr. Stephen Hill highlights in his research, this refusal to take rock stars at their own self-serious evaluation was not anti-intellectual. On the contrary, it exposed the vanity and commercial calculation of the music industry far more effectively than broadsheet polemics.
The Anatomy of Smash Hits House Style: Nicknames, Hyperbole, and High Lexicon
The defining triumph of the Smash Hits house style was its extraordinary linguistic dexterity. The magazine invented an entire sub-language of catchphrases, affectionate mockery, and absurd honorifics that rewarded attentive readers and built a distinct cultural community:
Irreverent Nicknames: Rock and pop aristocracy were routinely stripped of their solemnity. David Bowie became "Uncle David," Freddie Mercury was "Sir Fred," Gary Numan was "Numanoid," and prominent hitmakers were designated "Very Popular Rock Stars" (VPRSs).
The "Chortlesome" Register: Feature articles adopted the voice of a bemused, slightly eccentric schoolmaster or older sibling—using phrases like "veritable," "dreadful," "top notch," and "spiffing" to gently parody British establishment propriety.
Lexical Ambition: Despite addressing a teenage demographic, Smash Hits refused to use dumbed-down language. Articles were densely packed with sophisticated vocabulary, literary allusions, alliteration, and complex syntax, operating on Dave Hepworth’s editorial belief that young readers were naturally curious and eager to expand their worlds.
By combining high-brow vocabulary with low-brow pop enthusiasm, Smash Hits created a carnivalesque space where the formal boundaries of music criticism dissolved. A review of a heavy metal album or a synth-pop single was treated with the same meticulous linguistic care as a major feature, establishing a seamless editorial tone across every page.
The Pet Shop Boys Lineage: How Music Journalism Shaped Synth-Pop Genius
The connection between Neil Tennant’s editorial work at Smash Hits and his subsequent artistic output in Pet Shop Boys represents one of the most direct convergences of media theory and musical practice in modern pop history. When Tennant and Chris Lowe launched Pet Shop Boys, they brought the Smash Hits philosophy directly into the recording studio. Tracks like "West End Girls," "Opportunities (Let's Make Lots of Money)," and "It's a Sin" embodied the exact qualities Tennant had championed as a journalist:
Deadpan Irony: Observing consumer culture, stardom, and urban life with dry, detached amusement rather than rockist outrage.
Embrace of Artifice: Celebrating electronic synthesisers, polished studio production, and high-fashion visual imagery over "authentic" live guitar virtuosity.
High-Low Cultural Synthesis: Weaving references to T.S. Eliot, Soviet history, and disco rhythms into top-ten chart hits.
Ultimately, Neil Tennant’s legacy at Smash Hits demonstrates that the magazine’s linguistic revolution was far from a trivial footnote in media history. By dismantling the solemn orthodoxy of 1970s rockism and replacing it with an erudite, playful pop language, Smash Hits permanently altered how popular culture was written about, understood, and created.
Hill, S.A. (2009), Reconfiguring Authenticity in the Music Press 1978 to 1988 . PhD thesis. University of Southampton: Southampton.









Comments