top of page

Smash Hits: How a Pop Magazine Changed British Music Journalism

Writer: Dr Stephen HIll
Dr Stephen HIll
Nov 5
4 min read
Colorful infographic of Smash Hits magazine covers and text about how it changed British music journalism.

Smash Hits: How a Pop Magazine Changed British Music Journalism

When Smash Hits arrived on UK newsstands in November 1978, it presented an immediate sensory shock to the landscape of British music publishing. For over two decades, serious music journalism had been printed on smudgy broadsheet newsprint that left ink on the reader's fingers. Publications like the New Musical Express (NME), Melody Maker, and Sounds—collectively known as the "inkies"—were dominated by an earnest, text-heavy style derived from American New Journalism and counter-cultural rock ideology.


Smash Hits shattered this convention. Printed on high-gloss A4 paper in vivid Technicolor, the magazine celebrated the fleeting, brilliant surface of popular music. Conceived by former NME editor Nick Logan and published by East Midlands Allied Press (EMAP), Smash Hits did not merely report on the chart; it transformed how popular music was visually communicated, written about, and consumed.


1. From "Disco Fever" to Broad-Church Pop: Nick Logan’s Editorial Gambit


The institutional origin of Smash Hits reveals a fundamental clash between corporate media expectations and editorial vision. In 1978, EMAP was a provincial publishing operation based in Peterborough, best known for printing niche passion titles such as Angling Times and Motorcycle News. Seeking to capitalize on the global dance boom sparked by John Badham’s 1977 film Saturday Night Fever, EMAP management initially proposed launching a disco-dedicated publication titled Disco Fever.


Nick Logan, who had recently stepped down as editor of the NME after navigating the paper through its explosive punk era, vehemently resisted this single-genre constraint. As Logan recalled, he informed EMAP executives that if the magazine was restricted to disco, he would walk away from the project. Logan envisioned pop music as a broad church, insisting that the new magazine must feature punk and new wave acts alongside disco stars.


A test issue distributed in Middlesbrough in September 1978 featured Belgian pop artist Plastic Bertrand on the cover and punk outfit Sham 69 in the center spread. While initial test readers expressed ambivalence toward the punk content, they were captivated by the glossy paper stock. When the first official issue hit newsstands in November 1978, it featured Blondie’s Deborah Harry on the cover—establishing a visual template that bridged punk attitude with mainstream pop glamour. Published monthly for its first three issues, Smash Hits quickly moved to a fortnightly schedule, which it maintained for nearly three decades.


2. The Visual Grammar of Pop Art: Lyrics, Gloss, and Bedroom Culture


What distinguished Smash Hits from traditional music weeklies was its commitment to Pop Art aesthetics and visual presentation. Under the art direction of Steve Bush, who brought a refined visual typography to early issues laid out on Logan’s kitchen table, Smash Hits deployed vibrant pinks, bright yellows, and full-page color photography.


The magazine’s operational ballast was its reproduction of song lyrics, transcribed directly from seven-inch vinyl singles in a small Carnaby Street office by staff member Bev Hillier (later Soutar). This innovation served a dual purpose:


  • It provided essential cultural material for an adolescent audience eager to sing along to the radio and Top of the Pops.

  • It allowed the editorial team to cover massive commercial acts like ABBA or Bucks Fizz by printing their lyrics, while reserving full-length feature articles for artists the editorial team personally championed.


While broadsheet editors at the NME across Carnaby Street initially dismissed Smash Hits as a frivolous "playpen," the magazine assumed high levels of literacy and cultural capital from its readers. Under the editorship of Ian Cranna—who held a PhD in 17th-century history from the University of Edinburgh—and key writers like David Hepworth and Mark Ellen, Smash Hits adopted an urbane, ironic, and affectionately mocking house style. The prose avoided both turgid academic posturing and patronizing teen jargon, addressing its provincial readership as curious, intelligent participants in popular culture.


To highlight these contrasting editorial philosophies, the structural differences between traditional broadsheets and the new glossy format are outlined in the comparison below.

Structural Attribute

Traditional Inkies (NME, Melody Maker)

Smash Hits (1978–1981)

Format & Paper Stock

Broadsheet Newsprint (Black & White)

Glossy A4 (Full Colour)

Ideological Framework

Rockist Authenticity & Social Realism

Pop Artifice & Genre Parity

Primary Music Format

Long-Play Albums (LPs)

7-Inch Vinyl Singles & Chart Top 40

Journalistic Stance

Writer-as-Star / Polemical & Polyglottic

Witty, Ironic, Celebratory & Monoglottic

Target Audience

Metropolitan Connoisseurs & Roadies

Provincial Bedroom Pop Consumers

3. Reconfiguring Authenticity: The Peak of the Single and Televisual Pop


By locating its editorial focus on the UK singles chart between 1978 and 1981, Smash Hits captured a liminal golden age in British music history. As historical sales data demonstrates, this period represented the absolute peak of seven-inch single sales in the UK, culminating in 1979 with a record 86 million singles sold.


Rather than enforcing the rigid "rockist" boundaries of American music criticism—which privileged male guitar bands and anti-commercial sincerity—Smash Hits celebrated a diverse, post-punk/disco mainstream. In 1979 alone, the magazine’s front covers featured an eclectic range of genres without snobbery:


  • Punk & New Wave: The Clash, The Jam, The Buzzcocks, Sham 69

  • Pop & Disco: Blondie, Donna Summer, Kate Bush, ABBA

  • 2-Tone Ska & Synthpop: Madness, The Specials, Gary Numan’s Tubeway Army


As popular music scholar Simon Frith argues, popular music is fundamentally a studio-constructed form defined by a "televisual sensibility." Smash Hits embraced this reality. By using pin-sharp promotional stills and television performance imagery, the magazine reconnected British pop coverage with the playful, carnivalesque artifice first seen in 1950s titles like Disc and Record Mirror.


4. The Lasting Legacy of the Smash Hits Revolution


The early era of Smash Hits under Nick Logan and Ian Cranna proved that commercial pop culture could be treated with visual elegance and critical wit. Rather than denying pop's status as a commercial product, Smash Hitscelebrated its commodity status while dismantling the elite gatekeeping of the music press.


When Nick Logan departed in 1980 to found The Face, he carried the visual and editorial lessons of Smash Hits into the world of avant-garde style culture. Simultaneously, founding Smash Hits team members David Hepworth and Mark Ellen would later adapt the magazine’s monoglottic consumer guide format to launch Q Magazine in 1986.

By deconstructing the false dichotomy between artistic integrity and commercial pop, Smash Hits redefined British music journalism, leaving an indelible mark on magazine publishing and popular music studies.

Hill, S.A. (2009) Reconfiguring Authenticity in the Music Press 1978 to 1988 . PhD thesis. University of Southampton (University College Winchester


Comments


  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • vimeo

©2026 by Dr Stephen Hill

bottom of page