The History of British Music Magazines: From NME to Punk


The History of British Music Magazines: From NME to Punk
Before digital streaming, satellite TV, or social media, the British music press served as the primary gatekeeper of popular taste. Between the post-war decade and the late 1970s, titles like New Musical Express (NME) and Melody Maker evolved from modest trade sheets into influential cultural weapons. This evolution was not a simple linear march toward sophistication. Instead, it was a volatile contest between commercial chart coverage, high-minded jazz connoisseurship, American literary journalism, and working-class street politics.
Understanding how music magazines operated between 1950 and 1978 is essential for understanding how modern music criticism was built—and why the mid-1970s created the ideological conditions for the pop revolutions that followed.
1. The 1950s: Chart Obsession, Light Entertainment, and Pop Weeklies
The landscape of post-war British music publishing was split into two distinct editorial traditions: mainstream commercial pop papers and earnest specialist titles.
IPC’s New Musical Express (NME) was launched in 1952. Under owner Maurice Kinn, NME pioneered the UK's first weekly singles chart, using hit records by American artists like Frank Sinatra, Johnnie Ray, and Nat King Cole—and later Elvis Presley and Bill Haley—to drive sales. The early NME made no lofty claims about rock anti-commercialism; it was an unapologetic pop paper, closely tied to BBC radio stars, light entertainment, and chart popularity.
Magazine Title | Launch Year | Core Audience & Primary Editorial Focus |
Melody Maker | 1926 | Musicians and jazz connoisseurs; focused on instrumental technique and big bands. |
New Musical Express (NME) | 1952 | Mainstream chart consumers; focused on Top 30 singles and light entertainment stars. |
Record Mirror | 1956 | Consumer pop fans; published the UK's first album chart and early color layouts. |
Disc | 1958 | Teen pop audience; featured single glossy cover stars and promotional record shots. |
By contrast, Melody Maker—founded in 1926—viewed early rock ’n’ roll with deep suspicion. Directed primarily at working musicians and jazz enthusiasts, Melody Maker writers initially dismissed rock ’n’ roll as a "cheap and nasty" threat to musical integrity and traditional craftsmanship. Meanwhile, titles like Record Mirror (which introduced the first UK album chart in 1956) and Disc (which used full-page color cover shots of Buddy Holly and Ricky Nelson) began establishing the visual gloss that would shape teen pop magazines for decades.
2. The 1960s: The British Invasion and Rock Connoisseurship
The mid-1960s transformed British music journalism. The global success of The Beatles, The Rolling Stones, The Kinks, and The Who—collectively known as the "British Invasion"—reversed the traditional flow of pop authority from North America to the UK.
During this period, Melody Maker abandoned its hostility toward pop music. Writers like Chris Welch and Nick Jones began treating rock musicians not as fleeting teen idols, but as serious artists and instrumental virtuosos. Popularity and sales figures were no longer the sole criteria for critical acclaim. Influenced by jazz criticism, Melody Makerforged an autonomous critical stance that prioritized musical authenticity, improvisation, and progressive album statements over commercial chart singles.
At the same time, American publications were developing a new literary register:
Crawdaddy (1966): Founded by Paul Williams, it was the first magazine dedicated explicitly to rock criticism, launching writers like Jon Landau.
Rolling Stone (1967): Co-founded by Jann Wenner and Ralph Gleason, combining counterculture politics with jazz-inspired seriousness and broadsheet-style authority.
Creem (1969): Detroit-based, edgy, and anarchic, featuring Lester Bangs and celebrating raw garage rock over polished mainstream acts.
These US titles drew heavily on Beat Generation writers like Jack Kerouac and William Burroughs, forging a subjective, literary style that would quickly cross the Atlantic.
3. The 1970s "Polyglottic" Era: NME and New Journalism
By 1972, the British music press faced a circulation crisis. NME was perceived as out of touch with countercultural rock. The turning point arrived when editorial leadership shifted to Alan Smith and subsequently to 24-year-old Nick Logan in 1973.
Logan overhauled NME into a writer-centric paper heavily influenced by Tom Wolfe’s The New Journalism anthology. As media scholar Eamonn Forde observes, this created a "polyglottic" era characterized by fierce writer personalism. Rather than writing objective consumer reports, journalists wrote in the first person, positioning their subjective attachments and lifestyle at the center of the narrative.
Lead critics like Charles Shaar Murray and Nick Kent became stars in their own right. They approached rock music with intellectual intensity, cynicism toward record label hype, and deep reverence for romantic rock heroism—elevating artists like Led Zeppelin, David Bowie, The Velvet Underground, and Lou Reed.
4. Punk, Social Realism, and the "Hip Young Gunslingers"
When punk exploded in 1976, NME capitalized on the upheaval by launching a recruitment campaign for "Two Hip Young Gunslingers," hiring teenage writers Tony Parsons and Julie Burchill.
Parsons and Burchill brought an acerbic, working-class polemic to NME. While punk claimed to tear down the rock establishment, its journalistic coverage actually reinforced traditional notions of authenticity. As Keir Keightley's framework of rock ideology illustrates, punk combined modernist aesthetic destruction (demolishing progressive rock virtuosity) with romantic ideals of street-level realism, alienated social conditions, and audience-artist unity.
Journalists like Mick Farren and Julie Burchill framed punk not as commercial entertainment, but as an urgent response to urban decay, unemployment, and political disaffection. However, because radio disc jockeys shunned punk records and venues banned punk acts, the weekly music press became the essential conduit for the movement.
By 1978, NME reached circulations exceeding 200,000 copies per week. Yet beneath its radical rhetoric, the music press remained bound to a strict rockist ideology: anti-commercial, male-dominated, and suspicious of manufactured pop. It was precisely this earnest, smudgy broadsheet orthodoxy that Nick Logan would challenge when he stepped down from NME to launch Smash Hits in late 1978.
Hill, S.A. (2009) Reconfiguring Authenticity in the Music Press 1978 to 1988 . PhD thesis. University of Southampton (University College Winchester









Comments