top of page

From Jazz Critics to New Journalism: The Rise of the Music Writer

Writer: Dr Stephen HIll
Dr Stephen HIll
5 hours ago
6 min read
Infographic on music writers from jazz critics to new journalism, with trumpet, typewriter, magazine names, and a 1926-1978 timeline.

From Jazz Critics to New Journalism: The Rise of the Music Writer


Before popular music journalism evolved into the glossy, consumer-oriented buying guides of the 1980s, it underwent an explosive intellectual transformation during the 1960s and 1970s. What began as an earnest, technical trade press for jazz musicians was radically reshaped by the literary techniques of American Beat writing and New Journalism. This transatlantic exchange fundamentally altered how music was evaluated, elevating the rock critic from an anonymous reporter to an iconoclastic "cultural intermediary" and star in their own right.


Understanding this evolutionary arc—from the earnest jazz connoisseurship of Melody Maker to the ferocious first-person subjectivity of Lester Bangs, Nick Kent, and Charles Shaar Murray—is essential for understanding how the concept of musical authenticity was constructed prior to the post-punk era.


1. The Jazz Connoisseurship Baseline: From Technique to Taste

In the post-war era, British writing about popular music was split into two distinct categories. On one side stood the mainstream pop weeklies—titles like New Musical Express (launched in 1952), Record Mirror (1954), and Disc (1958)—which catered to teenage chart buyers and celebrated the visual gloss of 7-inch singles. On the other side stood Melody Maker, founded in 1926 by Lawrence Wright as a trade publication for working musicians.


For its first three decades, Melody Maker maintained an earnest, high-minded focus on jazz, big band arrangements, and instrumental technique. As media historians Gudmundsson et al. observe, when rock 'n' roll arrived in the mid-1950s, the paper's editorial staff viewed it with profound skepticism, treating raw rock 'n' roll as a threat to "good taste" and musical integrity.


The structural evolution of the British and American music press during this formative era can be mapped across distinct editorial philosophies and target audiences:

Period / Publication

Primary Music Focus

Editorial Philosophy & Target Audience

1950s Melody Maker

Jazz, Big Band, Swing

Technical, instructional; written for musicians; suspicious of commercial rock 'n' roll.

1950s NME & Disc

Chart Pop, Rock 'n' Roll

Mainstream, chart-driven; visual gloss; written for teenage single buyers.

Mid-1960s Melody Maker

Progressive Rock, Blues

Autonomous critical evaluation; jazz connoisseurship applied to rock virtuosity.

Late 1960s US Rock Press

Counterculture Rock

Literary, subjective, politically engaged; "rock criticism as art."

By the mid-1960s, however, a new generation of writers including Chris Welch, Richard Williams, and Steve Lake began applying the analytical tools of jazz criticism to emerging British blues and rock acts like Cream, The Who, and Jimi Hendrix. In doing so, Melody Maker established a new critical baseline: sales numbers and chart positions were no longer the decisive barometers of artistic worth. Instead, critical acclaim required autonomous evaluation, technical virtuosity, and a rejection of mere commercialism. When Chris Welch interviewed Eric Clapton in 1968 regarding the breakup of Cream, Clapton articulated a classic romantic vision of authenticity, rejecting the "pop image" in favor of "straight blues" and musical purity.


2. The American Countercultural Breakthrough: Crawdaddy, Rolling Stone, and Creem


While British weeklies slowly adapted their jazz frameworks to progressive rock, American rock criticism experienced a sudden, explosive genesis in the late 1960s. Prior to 1966, American pop coverage was largely confined to AM radio dials and teen fan magazines. That changed with the launch of Crawdaddy! in New York in 1966 by Paul Williams, billed as the first publication dedicated to serious rock 'n' roll criticism.


Crawdaddy! launched the careers of influential critics like Jon Landau and Richard Meltzer. Reviewing The Animals' album Animalization in 1966, Landau introduced a self-conscious, urbane analytical style that assumed high intellectual capability from the reader, contrasting sharply with the newsprint reporting of British weeklies.


This literary ambition reached full fruition with the founding of Rolling Stone in San Francisco in 1967 by Jann Wenner and veteran jazz critic Ralph J. Gleason. Gleason brought formidable gravitas to rock writing, positioning the counterculture's music alongside serious political and social commentary. Writers like John Mendelsohn brought a self-reflexive playfulness to album reviews—as in his famous 1969 review of The Beatles' Abbey Road—while deploying sophisticated musicological analysis to evaluate instrumental performances.

In 1969, Barry Kramer and Tony Reay launched Creem in Detroit as a raw, aggressive counterpoint to the increasingly mellow and established Rolling Stone. Unbound by corporate polite society, Creem embraced the gritty, confrontational garage rock of the Midwest—most notably MC5 and The Stooges—and pioneered an irreverent, gonzo style of criticism.


"In Creem, we talked to you as if you were smart, adventurous, and passionately committed to the music as a source of both fun and redemption." — Charles Shaar Murray


3. The Literary Impulse: Beat Writing, New Journalism, and Lester Bangs


The defining characteristic of 1970s American rock criticism was its explicit cross-pollination with literary movements, specifically 1950s Beat literature and Tom Wolfe's New Journalism. Writers like Lester Bangs, Greil Marcus, and Robert Christgau openly drew upon the spontaneous, idiomatic prose of Jack Kerouac's On the Roadand William S. Burroughs's Naked Lunch.


When Tom Wolfe published his seminal 1973 anthology The New Journalism (expanded in 1975), it featured rock critics alongside literary figures like Truman Capote, Norman Mailer, and Hunter S. Thompson (whose Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas had first appeared as a two-part serial in Rolling Stone in 1971). New Journalism dissolved the traditional boundary between objective reporter and subject through three key narrative devices:


  1. First-Person Participant Voice: The writer's subjective experience, emotional reaction, and personal neuroses became central to the narrative.

  2. Scene-by-Scene Reconstruction: Utilizing literary devices such as extended dialogue, internal monologue, and evocative atmospheric setting.

  3. Rejection of Institutional Neutrality: The review was treated as a creative literary text in its own right, equal in artistic weight to the album being discussed.


Nowhere was this more potent than in the writing of Lester Bangs at Creem. In landmark essays like his 1970 Stooges review, "Of Pop and Pies and Fun," Bangs deployed chaotic, rhythmic, taboo-shattering prose that sought to mirror the raw visceral impact of the music itself. Bangs established a fiercely romantic paradigm of authenticity: genuine rock 'n' roll was defined by savage honesty, emotional risk, and a refusal to compromise with slick commercial production.


4. Transatlantic Polyglottism: The NME and the "Critic-as-Star"


In the early 1970s, this American literary style migrated across the Atlantic and revolutionized the British music press. Facing declining sales in 1972, NME editor Alan Smith and assistant editor Nick Logan initiated a dramatic overhaul of the paper. Moving away from light-entertainment showbusiness coverage, NME began reprinting columns by Lester Bangs, Greil Marcus, and Robert Christgau while recruiting a new generation of British "personality writers."


Media scholar Eamonn Forde characterizes this golden era of NME as polyglottic—a chaotic, highly competitive ecosystem of distinct, warring authorial voices. Central to this approach was what Forde terms "personalism," where critics like Nick Kent and Charles Shaar Murray placed themselves at the very center of their features:


  • The "Hip Young Gunslingers": Writers cultivated larger-than-life personas, dressed like rock stars, and engaged in immersive, drug-fueled road trips with the bands they covered.

  • The "Critic-as-Star" Phenomenon: As Scottish musician Alex Harvey famously remarked to Charles Shaar Murray in a 1974 interview over a pint of bitter: "You and Nick Kent are in a far better position to become a pop star than any rock-and-roll singer—because anything that comes out has got to come via you."

  • Acerbic Polemics: When Nick Logan launched a recruitment drive in 1976 for "Two Hip Young Gunslingers," he hired Julie Burchill and Tony Parsons. Their ferocious, uncompromising prose turned NME into an intellectual battleground during the birth of punk.


5. The Ideological Legacy: Romantic Authenticity and First-Person Authority


By the mid-1970s, the British music press had established a powerful ideological framework around popular music. Grounded in Keir Keightley's model of romantic authenticity, this critical tradition privileged live performance, singer-songwriter authorship, working-class social realism, and an anti-commercial stance.


However, this "polyglottic" era contained an inherent paradox. While critics like Tony Parsons and Julie Burchill proclaimed an anti-establishment stance, their subjective authority relied on their status as elite gatekeepers within mass-market publishing corporations like IPC.


When Nick Logan launched Smash Hits in 1978 and The Face in 1980, followed by EMAP's launch of Q Magazine in 1986, this hyper-subjective, first-person "critic-as-star" model was systematically replaced. The new glossies introduced a more measured, corporate, and consumer-oriented register. Yet, the legacy of New Journalism remained profound: it proved that popular music was worthy of rigorous intellectual debate, literary ambition, and serious cultural analysis.



Hill, S.A. (2009) Reconfiguring Authenticity in the Music Press 1978 to 1988 . PhD thesis. University of Southampton (University College Winchester

Comments


  • facebook
  • twitter
  • instagram
  • vimeo

©2026 by Dr Stephen Hill

bottom of page