Punk, the NME and the Hip Young Gunslingers


Punk, the NME and the Hip Young Gunslingers
During the mid-1970s, the British music press underwent a fiery editorial transformation that permanently reshaped popular culture journalism. At the center of this upheaval was the New Musical Express (NME), which evolved from an out-of-touch weekly listing pop charts into an iconoclastic, countercultural powerhouse selling over 200,000 copies per week.
Driven by young editorial leadership, the influence of American New Journalism, and a new generation of acerbic writers dubbed the "Hip Young Gunslingers," NME captured the anger, social realism, and nihilism of the punk movement between 1972 and 1978.
However, while punk positioned itself as a total rupture with the past, the music press that documented it operated within a fascinating ideological paradox. Far from inventing a completely new critical framework, punk journalism reconfigured long-standing rockist mythologies of authenticity, fusing working-class social realism with romantic and modernist traditions of music criticism.
1. The NME Revolution: From Showbiz Weekly to Countercultural Vanguard
At the turn of the 1970s, NME was in severe commercial and editorial decline. Under veteran editor Andy Gray, the paper operated within an established light-entertainment tradition, selecting cover stories almost exclusively from the Top 30 singles chart. As staff writer and future editor Nick Logan recalled, the paper ignored album-oriented rock and countercultural movements that were driving sales at competitor titles like Melody Maker.
The turnaround began in 1972 when Alan Smith took over as editor and initiated a radical overhaul, reorienting NMEtoward the album-buying youth demographic. When Smith stepped down eighteen months later in 1973, 24-year-old Nick Logan was appointed editor. Logan’s appointment represented a drastic generational shift, placing a young writer at the helm of a major IPC publication.
Shortly after Logan assumed the editorship, a cathartic eight-week printing strike halted publication. Rather than stalling momentum, this forced hiatus provided the editorial team with space to execute a radical redesign. When NME returned to newsstands, it featured a bold new visual grammar—most notably replacing cluttered multi-photo covers with a single, high-impact front image—and an uncompromising editorial stance that instantly captured the changing mood of British youth culture.
2. The Polyglottic Era and the "Critic-as-Star"
Under Logan’s editorship, NME entered what media scholar Eamonn Forde terms its "polyglottic" era—a period defined by a competitive, highly individualistic roster of writers whose distinct voices scrambled for authority on the page.
To build credibility, NME recruited young writers like Nick Kent and Charles Shaar Murray. Both were heavily influenced by American New Journalism (such as Tom Wolfe, Hunter S. Thompson, and Lester Bangs) and Beat Generation literature (Jack Kerouac and William Burroughs). Their writing abandoned objective, third-person reporting in favor of intense first-person "personalism," positioning the critic as an active participant in the rock 'n' roll narrative.
The table below outlines the major stylistic and ideological shifts between 1950s/60s showbiz reporting and the polyglottic New Journalism of the 1970s:
Feature | Pre-1972 Showbiz Reporting | Polyglottic New Journalism (1972–1976) |
Writer Voice | Anonymous, promotional, reverential | Subjective, highly personal, cynical, "critic-as-star" |
Primary Focus | Top 30 singles chart & light entertainment | LP albums, counterculture, artist identity, rock mythology |
Literary Style | Standard newsroom prose | New Journalism, gonzo prose, literary and Beat influences |
Critical Stance | Industry-friendly publicity | Frontline skepticism, confrontation, aesthetic interrogation |
This "critic-as-star" phenomenon was famously articulated during a 1974 interview between Charles Shaar Murray and Scottish performer Alex Harvey. Over a pint of bitter, Harvey remarked to Murray that music journalists were in a better position to become pop stars than singers because every message was mediated through them. Murray drily noted in response: "Critic-as-star? A nice thought."
3. Hiring the "Hip Young Gunslingers": Julie Burchill and Tony Parsons
By 1976, as progressive rock grew increasingly bloated and detached from youth experience, NME sought fresh voices to cover the emerging punk underground. Logan placed a legendary advertisement in the paper looking for "Two Hip Young Gunslingers." The campaign procured seventeen-year-old Julie Burchill and nineteen-year-old Tony Parsons.
Burchill and Parsons brought an acerbic, uncompromising working-class polemic to NME. They treated music not as harmless entertainment, but as an urgent ideological battleground. In 1978, the duo co-authored The Boy Looked at Johnny: The Obituary of Rock and Roll, a furious indictment arguing that rock had become a corrupt, commercialized corpse.
Burchill’s writing for NME exemplified this ferocious reflexivity. In an October 1977 review of The Heartbreakers, she reflected on the limitations of punk as social revolution:
> "The latest vinyl communiqué from your favourite street fighting punks will have no bearing whatsoever on whether the button gets pressed or not... After rock 'n' roll as art-form/agent of social change/palliative come rock 'n' roll as reflex."
Burchill’s prose demonstrated that even at the height of punk, NME's young writers were deeply self-aware, constantly interrogating whether music could genuinely effect social change or merely simulate rebellion.
4. Social Realism vs. "Woodstock Syndrome": UK vs. US Punk Criticism
A defining feature of British punk journalism was its grounding in social realism and everyday material conditions. As popular music scholar Steve Jones notes, American rock critics had a tendency toward "Woodstock syndrome"—seeking grand, utopian narratives in rock music. In contrast, British critics during the mid-1970s tied music directly to the harsh realities of post-war British decline: unemployment, school life, the dole, neighborhood decay, and urban civil unrest.
This social realism was vividly captured in Mick Farren’s 1977 NME review of The Damned performing at the Manchester Apollo. Farren described the bleak urban landscape surrounding the venue:
"The Apollo and the adjoining pub stand rather forlornly in the middle of a vast tract of bleak scorched earth. The bulldozers have been and taken out the acres of back-to-back, Coronation Street terraces... In a landscape like this, it's all too logical for kids to turn to nihilist, Weimar Republic self-destruction to assert their own individuality."
By connecting the sonic violence of punk to demolished housing estates and rising youth unemployment, NMEestablished a tradition of UK music criticism that evaluated musical authenticity through the lens of lived social reality.
5. The Paradox of Punk Authenticity
While punk claimed to destroy the established rock canon, cultural historians note that punk journalism actually reinforced core rockist mythologies. As scholar Keir Keightley observes, rock ideology relies on two complementary modes of authenticity:
Romantic Authenticity: Valuing tradition, roots, community, populism, direct sincerity, and live performance.
Modernist Authenticity: Valuing experimentation, sudden stylistic shocks, irony, avant-garde deconstruction, and the rejection of established virtuosity.
Punk drew heavily on modernist authenticity to attack the bloated romanticism of 1970s stadium rock. Yet seminal texts of the era, such as the Sex Pistols’ 1977 album Never Mind the Bollocks, embodied both romantic and modernist sensibilities simultaneously. The album delivered a radical sonic shock while re-establishing a direct, populist connection between band and audience.
Ultimately, NME's coverage of punk sowed the seeds for the magazine publishing revolution that followed. By 1978, managing a maverick staff while acting as a buffer against IPC's corporate board had exhausted Nick Logan. Recognizing that the intense polemics of the "inkies" were reaching their natural limit, Logan stepped down from NME to launch Smash Hits—a glossy fortnightly that would take pop artifice, visual design, and consumer culture in a radically new direction.









Comments