How the British Music Press Changed Between 1978 and 1988


Hill, S.A. (2009) Reconfiguring Authenticity in the Music Press 1978 to 1988 . PhD thesis. University of Southampton (University College Winchester
How the British Music Press Changed Between 1978 and 1988
Between 1978 and 1988, the British music press underwent the most radical transformation in its publishing history. In the space of a single decade, the landscape of popular music journalism evolved from smudgy, newsprint broadsheets steeped in 1970s counter-cultural politics to polished, full-color glossy magazines that addressed their readers as sophisticated cultural consumers.
This transformation was not merely aesthetic or technological; it represented a fundamental reconfiguration of how musical value, cultural authority, and artistic authenticity were defined. By analyzing the decade bounded by the launch of Smash Hits in November 1978 and the consolidation of Q Magazine and The Face in the late 1980s, we can trace how British music writing exposed the myth of rock's anti-commercial purity and pioneered modern lifestyle publishing.
1. The Decade of Transformation: From Newsprint Broadsheets to Glossy Bibles
At the close of the 1970s, British music journalism was dominated by the "inkies"—weekly newsprint publications like NME (New Musical Express), Melody Maker, and Sounds. Under the editorship of Alan Smith and subsequently Nick Logan (who assumed the editor's chair at NME in 1973 at just 24 years old), these papers were written in a polemical, first-person style heavily influenced by American New Journalism and Beat literature. Writers like Nick Kent, Charles Shaar Murray, Julie Burchill, and Tony Parsons operated under an ideological framework that privileged "rockist" authenticity: the belief that genuine artistic integrity resided in raw, guitar-driven live performance, anti-commercial rebellion, and working-class social realism.
However, as Nick Logan recognized, this counter-cultural stance was increasingly out of step with the changing nature of popular music culture. The late 1970s saw an explosive collision of post-punk experimentation, 2-Tone ska, disco, and televisual pop artifice. Crucially, 1979 represented the absolute peak of 7-inch single sales in the UK, reaching an all-time record of 86 million singles sold. The mainstream singles chart was remarkably diverse, featuring hits ranging from Blondie’s Heart of Glass and Tubeway Army’s Are Friends Electric to The Police, The Jam, Donna Summer, Kate Bush, and Art Garfunkel.
The structural transition between the 1970s weeklies and the 1980s glossy titles can be mapped across four distinct publishing formats:
Late 1970s Inkies ( NME , Melody Maker ): Published as monochrome newsprint weeklies featuring dense prose, live performance photography, and romantic/modernist rockism that championed anti-commercial social realism for counter-cultural purists.
Late 1970s / Early 1980s Pop Glossies ( Smash Hits ): Published as fortnightly glossy A4 magazines in full color, featuring Technicolor typography, lyrics ballast, and video stills that celebrated pop artifice and Top 40 diversity for provincial teenagers and general pop fans.
1980s Metropolitan Style Bibles ( The Face , Arena ): Published as independent monthly glossies featuring Neville Brody’s experimental typography and avant-garde fashion layouts, framing authenticity as a modernist metropolitan style culture for urban insiders.
Late 1980s Adult Consumer Guides ( Q Magazine ): Published as monthly high-production glossies featuring structured album reviews and a 5-star rating system, reconfiguring authenticity into a commoditised heritage guide for adult CD collectors.
The shift initiated by Smash Hits in 1978, followed by The Face in 1980 and Q in 1986, proved that commercial pop culture could be treated with visual elegance, linguistic wit, and critical respect without capitulating to mindless boosterism.
2. Nick Logan and the EMAP Revolution: Institutional and Visual Redesign
The primary catalyst for this media revolution was Nick Logan. After editing NME through its mid-1970s heyday, Logan sought to escape the institutional friction between corporate publishers and maverick writing staff. Partnering with Peterborough-based publisher East Midlands Allied Press (EMAP), Logan launched Smash Hits in November 1978.
Initially conceived by EMAP publishers as a disco-focused title called Disco Fever to capitalize on Saturday Night Fever, Logan insisted on a much broader editorial vision that embraced punk, post-punk, new wave, and pop. In a test issue distributed in Middlesbrough in September 1978 featuring Plastic Bertrand on the cover and Sham 69 in the center spread, a printing paper shortage forced the issue onto heavy glossy stock. Readers loved the glossiness of the paper, and Logan threatened to walk if EMAP dropped the punk and new wave coverage. Combined with reproduction of song lyrics transcribed straight from 7-inch vinyl singles, full-color photography, and Art Director Steve Bush’s graphic design, Smash Hits created a vibrant visual syntax.
As Nick Logan recalled, his interest was in bringing excellent photography and lyric ballast together to showcase great acts to a young audience, whether it was The Jam, Blondie, or Elvis Costello, utilizing high-quality colour paper to make popular culture feel vital and immediate.
Logan followed this success in 1980 by independently funding The Face through his company Wagadon, operating initially out of the Smash Hits office. With graphic designer Neville Brody, The Face integrated music, street fashion, club culture, and typography, challenging traditional editorial hierarchies. Later in 1986, former Smash Hits editors David Hepworth and Mark Ellen launched Q Magazine under EMAP Metro, extending this glossy, high-production format to an older demographic of album buyers and Compact Disc collectors.
3. From Singular Rockism to Plural Poptimism: Deconstructing Authenticity
The most profound theoretical contribution of the 1978–1988 music press was the reconfiguration of musical authenticity. In traditional American rock ideology, as theorized by scholars like Keir Keightley and Simon Frith, "rock" was metonymic with sincerity, masculinity, and live performance, while "pop" was denigrated as feminine, manufactured, and artfully fake. Rock maintained what Jean Baudrillard termed a "deterrence machine"—claiming to exist outside consumer capitalism while operating entirely within record industry economics.
The new British music titles exposed this contradiction by openly celebrating pop's status as a commercial product across three core frameworks:
The Carnivalesque and Pop Artifice in Smash Hits: Rather than demanding solemnity or political posturing, Smash Hits re-engaged with a distinctly British art-school tradition. Drawing on a lineage from David Bowie and Roxy Music to punk and synth-pop, the magazine treated visual style, theatrical glamour, and 7-inch single artifice with affectionate, self-aware irony. It re-acquainted pop music with what Simon Frith describes as its "televisual sensibility," acknowledging that pop performance was constructed primarily for the screen and studio.
Avant-Garde Style Culture in The Face: The Face reframed authenticity as a cutting-edge, metropolitan style project. It treated subcultural fashion, graphic design, and clubbing as serious cultural practices, collapsing Pierre Bourdieu's boundaries between high art education and mass consumer taste.
Heritage and Canonization in Q Magazine: Launched alongside the rise of the Compact Disc and Live Aid retrospection, Q reconfigured authenticity into a commoditised consumer guide. Through its standardized 1-to-5 star rating system and retrospective features, Q validated classic album reissues and established a durable, adult rock canon.
4. The Cross-Pollination of Talent: How a Tight Network of Writers Shaped a Genre
Academic accounts sometimes treat the newsprint weeklies and the 1980s glossies as entirely hostile, antithetical movements. In reality, the evolution of the music press was driven by a tightly knit network of journalists and editors who moved fluidly across publications:
From NME to Smash Hits: Nick Logan left the editorship of NME in 1978 to launch Smash Hits, bringing along freelancers like Ian Cranna (who held a PhD in 17th-century history from the University of Edinburgh) and hiring young writers like David Hepworth and Mark Ellen.
From Smash Hits to The Face: Logan launched The Face in May 1980, working alongside Smash Hits Art Director Steve Bush to establish a new benchmark for independent style publishing.
From Smash Hits to Q Magazine: In 1986, David Hepworth and Mark Ellen co-founded Q Magazine under EMAP Metro, recruiting veteran NME writers like Charles Shaar Murray, Paul Du Noyer, and Nick Kent to review classic album reissues and contemporary releases.
Far from abandoning critical standards, writers like David Hepworth, Mark Ellen, Ian Cranna, Paul Du Noyer, and Charles Shaar Murray brought immense cultural capital and literary dexterity to the glossy titles. Smash Hitsdeployed a sophisticated lexical register—using mock-heroic tones, irony, and ambitious vocabulary—that refused to patronize its adolescent audience. When Hepworth, Ellen, and Du Noyer transitioned to Q, they adapted this editorial clarity to craft readable, objective consumer guides for adult readers.
5. The Lasting Legacy: How 1978–1988 Formed Modern Music and Lifestyle Media
The decade between 1978 and 1988 established the template for modern lifestyle publishing and music criticism. By proving that consumer journalism could coexist with intelligent cultural analysis, Smash Hits, The Face, and Q broke the monopoly of traditional rock weeklies.
The institutional strategies honed during this decade paved the way for the men's lifestyle magazine boom of the 1990s, including Arena, GQ, Mojo, Loaded, and FHM. Furthermore, by deconstructing the rigid binaries between rock and pop, the 1978–1988 music press anticipated today's digital music culture—where streaming algorithms, poptimist criticism, and visual media celebrate musical diversity across every genre.









Comments